It didn’t feel big enough—more like someone handed the CW Arrowverse crew an extra $100 million and told them to go nuts.
I really disliked their take on Lex Luthor. He came off as a childish little twerp, completely lacking the charisma and cold detachment that make Lex compelling. Having him shoot some random guy in the head just to rile up Superman felt like street-level thug behavior, not the calculated move of an arch-nemesis.
I also wasn’t a fan of the obvious attempt to rip off the Black Noir/Homelander dynamic from The Boys with Superman and Ultraman. It felt derivative.
That said, I did enjoy The Justice Gang, and I had no issue with Mr. Terrific, though it was hard to ignore that old trope where the Black character is needlessly abrasive and aloof for no reason.
I did appreciate that this Superman actually felt like someone from Earth, with realistic emotions and empathy. I loved that he prioritized saving people (and animals) over punching stuff. That was one of my biggest problems with the reckless Superman in Man of Steel.
I also liked Supergirl’s look at the end, and I genuinely appreciated that they put Metropolis in Delaware. I can’t stand it when comic-book cities are just vague, unanchored places.